Critics Hail 'Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812' as a Theatrical Triumph at the Donmar

The Donmar Warehouse's production of Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 has emerged as the most talked-about show in London, with critics universally praising this rather remarkable UK premiere of Dave Malloy's innovative musical.

The Production

Tim Sheader's staging of this adaptation of a slice of Tolstoy's 'War and Peace' has proved nothing short of revolutionary in its approach to immersive musical theatre. The production, which opened on 9 December and runs until 8 February 2025, has garnered exceptional reviews across the board.

Critical Response

WhatsOnStage's Sarah Crompton leads the praise, describing the production as "hugely entertaining and deeply intelligent" in a five-star review. The Guardian awards four stars, declaring that "the singing blows the roof off" in what they term a "terrific riff on Tolstoy."

Innovative Staging

The critics have been particularly impressed by the production's creative use of the Donmar's intimate space. The atmosphere, as noted by WhatsOnStage, is "intense, but always lively," with jugglers and dancers creating a vibrant, immersive experience through Ellen Kane's "punchy choreography."

Standout Performances

The ensemble cast has earned particular praise, with The Stage highlighting "jaw-dropping performances" throughout. Declan Bennett's Pierre and Maimuna Memon's Sonya have drawn specific acclaim, though some critics note interesting quibbles about Bennett's interpretation of the leading role.

Musical Excellence

Dave Malloy's score, which blends Russian folk music with contemporary indie-rock and electronic elements, has received unanimous praise. Critics particularly note how the musical arrangements serve both the narrative and the emotional core of Tolstoy's story whilst creating something entirely fresh and contemporary.

Production Elements

The technical aspects of the production have garnered significant attention:

• The immersive staging transforms the Donmar's intimate space

• The lighting design creates multiple atmospheric environments

• The costume design brilliantly bridges period and contemporary elements

• The sound design balances the complex score with theatrical immediacy

This production represents a significant moment in British musical theatre, demonstrating how classical literature can be reimagined for contemporary audiences whilst maintaining artistic integrity. Its success suggests a bright future for innovative musical theatre in London.

Audience Response

Early audience reactions have matched the critical enthusiasm, with particular praise for:

• The immersive nature of the production

• The energy and commitment of the ensemble

• The accessibility of the complex narrative

• The emotional impact of the performances

Technical Achievement

The production team has received particular praise for transforming the Donmar into an immersive theatrical environment that serves both the narrative and the music. The integration of various technical elements creates what The Stage describes as a "seamless theatrical experience."

The success of this production at the Donmar Warehouse reinforces London's position as a centre for innovative musical theatre. It demonstrates how smaller venues can create theatrical experiences that rival larger West End productions in terms of impact and artistic achievement.

Looking Forward

The production's success bodes well for future innovative musical theatre projects in London. It has set a new standard for immersive musical staging whilst proving that complex source material can be made accessible and entertaining without sacrificing artistic integrity.

The overwhelming critical response suggests that this production represents a significant achievement in contemporary musical theatre. Its blend of innovative staging, strong performances, and musical excellence has created what many critics consider a landmark production.

---

For the latest theatre news, reviews, and ticket information, visit British Theatre. Your premier source for all things theatre in the UK.